NewCulture.Co

How Do I Run an SEO Audit on My Website?

By Jon Horton··6 min read
How Do I Run an SEO Audit on My Website?

At some point, every website owner asks the same quiet question: is this thing actually working?

So you search "how do I run an SEO audit," and what comes back is a wall of tools trying to sell you a subscription, agencies trying to sell you a call, and 40-page PDFs that bury the one thing you wanted—a straight answer.

Here's the straight answer.

To run an SEO audit on your website, work through seven checks in order: confirm Google can find your pages, check your page structure, test speed and mobile experience, review your titles and descriptions, match your content to what people actually search, verify your Google Business Profile, and read your Search Console data. Then fix things in priority order—not all at once.

That's the whole shape of it. The rest of this post walks you through each step in plain language, with the free tools to use and the traps to skip. You can do all of it today, and most of it costs nothing.

What Is an SEO Audit?

An SEO audit is a structured checkup of your website that answers one question: what is keeping this site from being found on Google? It looks at whether your pages are indexed, whether they're built in a way search engines can read, whether they load fast, and whether the content matches what your customers actually type into the search bar.

It's a diagnosis, not a treatment. The audit tells you what's wrong and what to fix first. The fixing comes after—and it goes much faster when you're aiming at the right things. If you want the deeper picture of what a professional version includes, I've written about what a website SEO audit actually covers.

Step 1: Confirm Google Can Find Your Pages

Everything starts here. If Google hasn't indexed your pages, nothing else on this list matters—you can't rank for a race you're not in.

The two-second test: go to Google and search site:yourdomain.com (no space after the colon). What comes back is every page of yours Google knows about. If your important pages are missing, or the count is way off from how many pages you really have, you have an indexing problem—usually a stray noindex tag or a blocked robots file, and usually fixable in an afternoon.

Then set up Google Search Console if you haven't. It's free, it's Google's own tool, and it will tell you flatly which pages are indexed, which aren't, and why.

Step 2: Check Your Page Structure

Google reads your site like an outline: one clear title per page, headings in order, descriptions that say what the page is about, structured data that tells it what kind of business you are. When that outline is broken or missing, Google guesses. And it guesses wrong more often than you'd like.

You could check all of this by hand, view-source and squinting. Or you can let a tool do it in seconds.

This is exactly why we built Findable—a free Chrome extension that scans any page you're on and shows you the structural problems Google sees: missing titles, broken heading order, absent meta descriptions, missing structured data and social tags. One click, a page-level score, and a plain list of what's broken. Run it on your homepage right now, then run it again after you fix things. It's free, and it stays free.

Step 3: Test Speed and Mobile Experience

Slow pages lose people, and Google knows it. More than half of your visitors are on a phone, and if your site takes five seconds to load, most of them are gone before it does.

Run your homepage through PageSpeed Insights—Google's free testing tool. Look at the mobile score first, because that's how most of your customers experience you. You're not chasing a perfect 100. You're looking for the big offenders: giant uncompressed images, plugins stacked on plugins, themes doing too much. Fixing the top two or three usually moves the needle more than anything else on this list.

Step 4: Review Your Titles and Descriptions

Every page on your site has a title tag and a meta description—the headline and preview text Google shows in search results. They're also your first impression, and most small business sites waste them.

Walk your key pages and ask one question about each title: if a stranger read only this, would they know what the page offers and who it's for? "Home | Smith LLC" tells nobody anything. "Guitar Repair in Goldsboro, NC | Smith Guitar Works" tells Google and the customer exactly what's behind the click.

Step 5: Match Your Content to What People Actually Search

This is the step most audits skip, and it's the one that decides whether the traffic ever converts.

List the five searches you most want to be found for—what you do plus where you do it, in your customer's words, not your industry's. Then check honestly: do you have a page that genuinely answers each one? Not mentions it. Answers it.

If the answer is no, that's not a failure—that's your content plan for the next quarter. Pages that answer real searches are how small sites beat bigger ones.

Step 6: Verify Your Google Business Profile

If you serve a local area, your Google Business Profile is arguably more valuable real estate than your website—it's what shows up in the map results, where local customers actually click. Make sure it's claimed, the categories are right, the hours are current, and the reviews are being answered. I've walked through the whole setup in how to get your business on Google Maps.

Step 7: Read Your Data

The last step is the one that turns a one-time audit into an ongoing advantage: look at what Search Console and Analytics are already telling you. Which searches bring people in? Which pages do they land on? Where do they leave?

You don't need to become a data person. You need three or four numbers, checked regularly, so that next month you're comparing against something instead of guessing. Here's how to check if your SEO is actually working without drowning in dashboards.

Can I Do an SEO Audit Myself for Free?

Yes. Every step above can be done free: the site: search costs nothing, Search Console and PageSpeed Insights are free Google tools, and the Findable extension is free forever. A motivated owner with a spare afternoon can find most of what's holding their site back.

I've put the full checklist version—with the exact order and what-to-do-abouts—in the DIY SEO audit checklist. Start there if you're doing this solo.

How Long Does an SEO Audit Take?

A DIY audit using the steps above takes two to four hours for a typical small business site. A professional audit typically takes one to two weeks, because a human is reviewing your competitors, your data history, and the technical layers underneath. The fixes themselves range from an afternoon (titles, images, profile cleanup) to a few months (content building)—and results follow their own honest timeline.

How Much Does an SEO Audit Cost?

Doing it yourself costs nothing but time. Automated tool reports run free to about $100—useful, but they can't tell you which of the 200 flagged items actually matters. Professional audits from a real person typically run $500 to $3,000 depending on the size of your site. Ours is $999, flat: a real review of your site, your data, and your competitors, delivered as a short prioritized plan in plain English. I've broken down what an SEO audit should cost—and the pricing games to watch for—separately.

How Often Should You Run an SEO Audit?

Run the full checkup once or twice a year, and any time something big changes—a redesign, a platform move, a sudden traffic drop. (Redesigns especially: they break more SEO than almost anything else.) In between, the structural stuff deserves a quick look monthly.

But here's the honest truth about audits: the sites that win aren't the ones that audit occasionally. They're the ones where somebody is watching all the time.

That's what Findable Pro is. For $95/month, it connects your Search Console and Analytics once, scans your whole site, tracks your keywords in a live portal, and—this is the part no tool does—sends you a monthly report written by a person, telling you in plain English what changed and exactly what to do next. It's the audit, running continuously, with an expert reading the results so you don't have to. You can see everything it includes on the pricing page, and the first scan is free.

Your One Step

Don't try to do all seven steps today.

Do step one. Open Google, type site:yourdomain.com, and look at what comes back. Ten seconds, and you'll know whether Google can even see you—which is the one thing every other fix depends on.

If the pages are there, move to step two tomorrow. If they're not, you just found the most important problem on your list, and it's fixable.

Either way, you're no longer wondering. You're working the list. And a short list of specific, fixable things beats a vague worry every single time.

The people searching for what you do are out there right now. I believe they should be able to find you—and now you know how to make sure they can.

Free Download

Get the 10-Point SEO Checklist

The same checks I run first — in plain English, sorted by what to fix first. Drop your email and it's in your inbox in two minutes, plus a short series on getting your website found.

No spam. Unsubscribe any time. You'll get the checklist plus a short series on getting your website found on Google.

Jon Horton

About the Author

Jon Horton is the founder of NewCulture. With 20+ years in technology and digital strategy, he helps businesses, nonprofits, and churches build their online presence and reach more people.

Keep Reading

More from the Blog